Music Download Warning List

audio-player.js or player.swf were not found in /sites/all/modules/contrib/mp3player/mp3player/, download the standalone WordPress Audio Player.

Music Download Warning List

July 1, 2008

Beware of Potentially Deceptive Fee-Based Download Services

Thinking of signing up and paying money to a music download service that looks legitimate and perhaps even claims to be "legal?"

Check our list first.

Unfortunately, some sites may be happy to take your money, and may leave you with the impression that they are legal sources of a full range of music - including the top performers and music labels - but they are not licensed distributors of at least a substantial quantity of mainstream music. In particular, the sites on our list promote themselves in ways that suggest their music catalog is relatively comprehensive, when in fact they appear to have done nothing to license or otherwise ensure the legality of any downloads from the major music labels. Even where these sites include “legal information� cautioning users against illegal downloading, that information is not sufficiently clear, or prominent, or specific to prevent users from mistakenly perceiving the sites as sources of lawful copies of most mainstream music.

In short, if you are an Internet user in the United States and you pay money to one of these services with the intention of being a lawful online music user, you may get less than you bargained for.

CDT Complaint to FTC re:Mp3DownloadCity.com and MyMusicInc.com

March 8, 2005

The Center for Democracy and Technology (CDT) files this Complaint and Request for Relief with the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) seeking immediate action to prevent harm to Internet users as a result of deceptive advertising by Mp3DownloadCity and MyMusicInc (hereinafter “download websites”) and/or their subsidiaries and/or affiliates. This matter is within the Commission’s jurisdiction over unfair and deceptive trade practices.

The download websites claim to offer “100% legal” downloads in exchange for a subscription fee. In fact, they merely point users to filesharing software and provide instructions for its use. Users of these sites users are led to believe that they are purchasing a license to download and use songs and movies—much like they would on a licensed subscription service like Rhapsody or the new Napster.1 In fact, users are provided no such license, and if they follow the sites’ explicit invitations to download “movies still in theatres” or music by the Beatles and the Rolling Stones, they may face substantial legal liability.